Dammit to hell. Or as Libby (my Canberra coz) would say, bugger shit bum.
Several bad days on the trot. Bad as in research. Bad as in time spent, wasted, reinventing the wheel; not just any wheel but my own wheel. Bad as in wasting an entire day and $12 on a trip to Manly (so-called, by the way, by Governor Phillip to describe the natives he first saw there).
Manly is on the north side of Sydney Harbour. It’s a bit like Blackpool with a glorious beach, and wonderful surfing if you’re into that kind of thing. It has a kind of seedy, worn-at-the-edges glamour, or perhaps tackiness would be nearer the mark. It’s a lovely trip across the harbour though, except the day I went was overcast and quite cold, too cold to sit outside and enjoy the views.
I was heading for the library to try to discover more about my great grandfather and my great great grandfather, both of whom lived there, in the same house called ‘Fairlight’, though not necessarily at the same time. My great grandfather in particular was quite a notable local I believe, and was partly responsible for the planting of the Norfolk pines fringing the surf beach. He also gave away part of his land to the council for which he was made an honorary lifelong member of the local cricket club, though to my knowledge he had no particular interest in cricket. And since ‘Fairlight’ was rented, it did not belong in the family, I’m not sure where the land he gave away came from. It’s that and other details I am here to discover.
But the nice young librarian tells me I should have booked an appointment. I’m not sure who with, because she explains there was a ‘volunteer’ who could help with family history, only he or she is away on leave. There was also a local enthusiast who was passionate about the history of Manly apparently and spent almost all of his time in the library, though not today regrettably.
So I passed a desultory hour or so in the family history section, logging onto obscure websites and looking through some of the books on the shelves and occasionally coming upon the odd reference to my great grandfather which, as it turned out, had already been come upon by my aunt Barbara several years ago. That’s what I mean about reinventing the wheel. The moment I found a reference – ah! – it turned out I’d read it before. I don’t think I discovered anything new all day.
The next day I spent in the Mitchell Library. Most of the time I’ve spent here has been trying to uncover something my aunt Barbara has not already uncovered. So far the only ‘new’ things have been to do with the local history of the period, gleaned mostly from the Historical Records of New South Wales. I am a lot more interested in the historical context than aunt Barbara was, partly because she lives here and no doubt knows about it already, and partly because I cannot see how any book about one’s ancestors can be of any interest or make much sense unless there is a canvas to place the pieces onto, to use a clumsy analogy.
I did come upon one ‘new’ and interesting item, the original of a letter written to my ancestress Mary Pitt by a Lieutenant Braithwaite, who went to visit her on board the ship Canada while she was waiting to sail to New South Wales. They had not met before but he visited her at the suggestion of a mutual (unnamed) friend to fill her in on life in the colony, where he had served several years in the army. Precisely what he said to her is not recorded, but he must have put the fear of God into her because the following day she wrote to her cousin George – whose idea it was she migrate in the first place – to say how much she was dreading going to ‘that wicked place’. This letter, which I was allowed to transcribe in pencil, was written by Braithwaite to cousin George describing some of the conditions allowed to free settlers in the new colony (although with no details of ‘this wicked country’).
So that was quite a good start. Next I ordered up some documents purporting to be the original letters written by Lord Nelson and Co concerning my ancestress’ migration, but they turned out to be handwritten copied transcripts, oddly tacked onto a family tree in such an obscure way that it took me several goes through the microfilm to see them, and there was also something about land granted to Thomas Pitt in the early 1800s which I think is inaccurate.
So that was another day gone. Yes, it took that long, to fill in the slips, wait at the desk for someone to hand them in to, go away for half an hour while the items were fetched up, wind the microfilm through the machine, look at the stuff, fail to find what you’re looking for, look through it again, in one instance seeking help because the item in question clearly was not there (it was, I just couldn’t find it), going through the whole rigmarole again because you can only order three items at a time, and at the end of it realising you’ve learned nothing new, nothing at all, all you’ve done is reinvent your auntie’s wheel, or in fact in the case of Margaret Catchpole reinventing your own wheel, that’s as in going over the same old stuff time and again.
So now I am asking myself – why am I doing this? Who gives a damn? It’s hard work, it’s time-consuming, it’s frustrating, exasperating, boring, and for what? What makes a family interesting? Why should anyone care about where and who they came from? All it is in the end is a list of names and places. Meaningless.
On the other hand. My family is interesting. Extremely interesting, actually. First, they were genuine pioneers. They were some of the first people to build a new country, to go where nobody, no white man that is, had ever gone before, to farm land that had never before been farmed and build where no building had ever stood. If they needed a hospital, or a school, or a shop even, they had to get together to raise the resources to build it. There were no safety nets, no welfare state, it was every person for himself, making it up as they went along.
So they were entrepreneurs. They had to be. They built things out of nothing, they had to. They had energy, and courage, confidence, creativity and … all the things I don’t have. So what happened? Where did it all go wrong?
I’ve managed to track down a distant relative who is writing a book about the Pitt family. She sounded reasonably friendly and reasonably interested to hear from me. Her book, which she is just finishing off now, covers all of Mary Pitt’s offspring, all five of them, which is a pretty huge task, or ask, seeing as how many children her children and her children’s children produced over the centuries, which is why she has been working on the book for five years.
Five years! I’ve only been doing it for three months and I am already thinking I’ve had enough. She has been through all the land titles, discovered who owned what piece of land and when and for how long, whose in-laws ran what companies and lost what fortunes and goodness knows what else. I have asked her to send me her book, or extracts from it, so I can fill in any ‘gaps’. I don’t suppose for a moment there will be any gaps, I’m sure she’s done a very thorough job; what I’m really wanting is to get information from her, especially about the boring stuff like land titles.
But is this fair? Is it fair that someone should have spent so long poring over documents to do with titles and grants and probates and collated all the information only for somebody to come along and pinch it all? I feel vaguely bad about this. I don’t for a moment believe there is anything I can tell her she hasn’t already uncovered.
It’s a tricky one. It’s a question I could have raised at the Society of Genealogists, which I had intended visiting yesterday. But when it came to it .. to be honest I couldn’t be bothered. After two virtually fruitless days I didn’t know what I was going there for, even though really the purpose of going was not to discover anything specific but just to look, and maybe discover something of real interest, maybe not. SAG, as it is endearingly called, is a place where people who’ve been researching their family history can log their findings, so other people can have access to them. I know aunt Barbara has done this, and it’s possible other members of the (vast) Pitt family who I don’t know about have done it also. But I never got there, so maybe I will never know.
Where is the Pioneering Pitt spirit when you need it??